Skip to Content

Where To Sell Beanie Babies For Cash? (For Real!)

Where To Sell Beanie Babies For Cash 

Beanie babies are a type of soft toy that was popular in the 1990s. In fact, it is not wrong to say that they were the most popular collectible out there.

If you’re looking to sell your old beanie babies or buy a few beanie babies, there are a few different options available to you.

You could try selling them online through sites like eBay or Craigslist, or you could take them to a local pawn shop or antiques dealer.

That means, you beanie babies can be flipped around easily and may sell for a pretty high price (yes, you read it right)

In this post, we will go over  some of the places where you can sell your beanie babies for cash but before that –

Note – This post may contain affiliate links and sponsored listings. Please read disclosure policy.

Want to make money quickly? Here are a few platforms to earn up to $25 – $50 in a few minutes!

How much can you make selling beanie babies for cash?

It will depend on a number of factors such as the condition of your beanie babies, how rare they are, and where you sell them.

While your beanie babies may not sell for more than $20-50, but if its rare and have a historic event attached, it might for few hundreds of dollars. The value, basically, shoots up.

What determines how much you can make selling beanie babies?

Whether you’re selling pokemon cards or beanie babies, the price will eventually depend on a number of factors

The rarity of the beanie baby, as well as its condition, affects how much someone can make when selling the toy. For instance, older beanie babies that are in good condition and come with a certificate for its authenticity can be worth a lot more than those that are newer and in worse condition.

Additionally, beanie babies that have unique designs or are from earlier generations can also fetch a higher price.

Finally, the tags that come with the toy (especially the tush tag) can also add to its value.

To give you an overview:

  • Generation affects the price because it determines how rare the beanie babies are. 
  • Rarity affects the price because it determines how many people have the beanie baby. 
  • Condition affects the price because it determines how good the beanie baby looks. 
  • Certificate of Authenticity affects the price because it guarantees that the beanie baby is real. 
  • Hang Tags affect the price because they show how much care was put into making the beanie baby. 
  • Tush Tags affect the price because they show that the beanie baby is authentic. 
  • It’s history affects the price because it can make a beanie baby more or less valuable.

Do people really buy beanie babies for cash?

Yes,  people do buy beanie babies, and they are willing to pay good money for them. In fact, there is a thriving market for beanie babies, and you can find buyers both online and offline.

Of course, the amount of money that you can make selling your beanie babies will depend on a number of factors as we discussed.

Where to sell beanie babies for cash?

eBay

eBay is a great place to sell beanie babies for cash. There are a number of buyers and sellers on the site, so you’re likely to find a buyer quickly.

In fact, they have a section for selling beanie babies separately. Additionally, eBay offers protection to buyers and sellers, so you can feel confident that your transaction will go smoothly.

All this said, remember that you need to handle shipping at your cost and the fee is quite high.

Pros on selling Beanie Babies on eBay

  • Large audience, both national and international
  • List your beanie babies with description and pictures
  • Promote your listings for better results
  • Provides equal protection to the buyer and seller

Cons on selling Beanie Babies on eBay

  • High fee, approx 15% of the final sale value.
  • You need to package and ship the card yourself.
  • The process of listing, promoting and delivering can be time-consuming.

PlushCollector

PlushCollector is a website devoted exclusively to selling beanie babies and other plush toys. If you’re looking to sell your beanie babies online, PlushCollector is a good option.

The site has a large audience of collectors who are likely to be interested in your toy.

The best part, you can just sell your beanie babies to them and they will pay you instantly. Meaning, you don’t deal with clients directly.

While you may have to cover your shipping, Plush Collector does send you shipping labels if your selling order is more than $25.

The only drawback of this site – beanie babies are definitely undervalued and if you sold it directly to a collector, you will have a better profit margin.

Pros on selling Beanie Babies on Plush Collector

– Large audience of collectors

– You don’t have to deal with clients directly

– They send you shipping labels if your order is over $25

Cons on selling Beanie Babies on Plush Collector

– Beanie babies are undervalued on this site

– You have to cover shipping yourself

Etsy

Etsy is a popular site for selling handmade goods. If you’ve made your own beanie baby, Etsy is a good place to sell it.

The site has a large audience of buyers who are looking for unique items. Remember that, there is a listing fee of $0.20 per item and a seller fee of up to 5% for transactions.

Once you decide to go ahead with Etsy, just find out the beanie babies you have and check the selling price.

Pros on selling Beanie Babies on eBay

– Popular site for selling handmade goods

– Large audience of buyers

– Easy to use listing process

Cons on selling Beanie Babies on eBay

– Listing fee of $0.20 per item

– Seller fee of up to 5% for transactions

Sell2BBNovelties

Sell2BBNovelties is another site devoted exclusively to selling beanie babies and other plush toys.

This site has a smaller audience than PlushCollector, but it may be a good option if you don’t have many options or if you’re looking for a faster sale.

Similar to PlushCollector, all you have to do is send them a query, get an estimated quote, and ship to them for evaluation.

They have a lookup feature where you can put up the barcode number which is on your beanies babies and check the prices.

All this said, they only buy mint condition beanie babies and you will get free shipping labels if the total worth is over $30.

Pros on selling Beanie Babies on eBay

– You don’t have to deal with clients directly

– Free shipping labels if the total order is over $30

Cons on selling Beanie Babies on eBay

– Smaller audience than some other sites

– They only buy mint condition beanie babies

Sell4Value

Sell4Value is a general auction site where you can sell Beanie Babies and other items.

The site has a large audience of buyers, so your item is likely to get exposure here. However, the competition may be higher than on some of the other sites listed here

Where To Sell Beanie Babies For Cash Near Me (ONLINE)?

Facebook Marketplace

You can also try selling your Beanie Babies on Facebook Marketplace.

It’s similar to using a Facebook group, but with the added benefit of being able to use Marketplace’s built-in payment system, which offers some protection against fraud.

To sell on Marketplace, just take a photo of your product, add a description and set a price. When someone messages you about the product, you can then arrange to meet up and complete the sale.

Pros:

  • Free to list
  • Can reach a lot of people with high purchase intent
  • Facebook’s built-in payment system offers some protection against fraud

Cons:

  • You have to meet up with the buyer in person, which can be unsafe
  • Everything needs to be done manually (e.g. creating listings, taking photos) which is tedious
  • You can still be scammed if you’re not careful

8. Craigslist

Craigslist is one of the oldest online marketplaces, and while it’s not as popular as it once was, it’s still a good place to list your beanie babies for sale.

To list on Craigslist, just find your local Craigslist site, create a listing and wait for someone to message you about the product. You can then arrange to meet up and complete the sale.

Pros:

  • Can reach a lot of people
  • Local focus means you can sell your beanie babies fast

Cons:

  • You have to meet up with the buyer in person, which can be unsafe
  • Everything needs to be done manually (e.g. creating listings, taking photos) which is tedious
  • You can still be scammed if you’re not careful

Offerup

Offerup is a mobile app that’s similar to Craigslist, but with a nicer interface and some additional features.

To sell on Offerup, just take a photo of your product, add a description and set a price. When someone messages you about the product, you can then arrange to meet up and complete the sale.

Pros:

  • Can reach a lot of people
  • Offerup’s interface is nicer than Craigslist’s

Cons:

  • You have to meet up with the buyer in person, which can be unsafe
  • Everything needs to be done manually (e.g. creating listings, taking photos) which is tedious
  • You can still be scammed if you’re not careful

Where To Sell Beanie Babies For Cash (OFFLINE)?

Flea Markets

Flea markets are a great place to sell beanie babies, especially if you have a lot of them.

To sell at a flea market, just set up your stall and start selling. You’ll need to be prepared to haggle with buyers, as this is expected at flea markets.

Pros:

  • Can reach a lot of people
  • You can sell your beanie babies fast

Cons:

  • Everything needs to be done manually (e.g. setting up your stall, taking payments) which is tedious
  • You might have to carry the entire beanie babies collection which is tedious

Garage Sales

Garage sales are similar to flea markets, but they’re usually smaller and more localised.

To sell at a garage sale, just set up your stall and start selling. You’ll need to be prepared to haggle with buyers, as this is expected at garage sales.

Pros:

  • Can reach a lot of people
  • You can sell your beanie babies fast

Cons:

  • Everything needs to be done manually (e.g. setting up your stall, taking payments) which is tedious

Pawn Shops

Pawn shops are a good place to sell beanie babies if you need cash fast.

To sell at a pawn shop, just take your product to the pawn shop and negotiate a price with the staff. If you agree on a price, they’ll give you cash for your product and you can leave the store.

Pros:

  • You can get cash for your beanie babies quickly

Cons:

  • You’ll probably get less money for your product than if you sold it somewhere else
  • They might not be interested in beanie babies collection

Local collectibles shop:

Local collectibles shops are a good place to sell beanie babies if you want to get a fair price for them.

Just go on Google and search for  “local collectibles shops” to find one near you. Once you’ve found a shop, take your product in and negotiate a price with the staff. If you agree on a price, they’ll give you cash for your product and you can leave the store.

Pros:

  • You can get cash for your beanie babies quickly
  • The staff will be knowledgeable about beanie babies and can give you a fair price

Cons:

  • You might have to travel to the store, which can be inconvenient
  • The staff might not be interested in your product

Local toy store:

Local toy stores are a good place to sell beanie babies if you want to get a fair price for them. They might also be interested in buying your entire collection.

Just go on Google and search for  “local toy store” to find one near you.

Once you’ve found a shop, take your product in and negotiate a price with the staff. If you agree on a price, they’ll give you cash for your product and you can leave the store.

Pros:

  • You can get cash for your beanie babies quickly
  • The staff will be knowledgeable about beanie babies and can give you a fair price
  • They might be interested in buying your entire collection

Cons:

  • You might have to travel to the store, which can be inconvenient

Tips For Selling Beanie Babies

Know the value of your beanie babies:  Before you list your beanie babies for sale, research the going rate for similar items. This will help you to set a fair price, and it will also give you an idea of what to expect in terms of offers from buyers.

For example, look for  original 9 Beanie Babies which are more valuable. The top 5 most valuable and pricey beanie babies are;

  • Jolly the Walrus: $75,000
  • Batty: $125,000
  • Piccadilly Attic: $125,000
  • Bubbles the Fish: $129,000
  • Princess Bear: $500,000

You can find more about it here.

Take good photos: When selling online, the quality of your photos can make a big difference in whether or not people are interested in your product. Make sure to take clear, well-lit photos of your beanie babies from different angles.

Be prepared to haggle: When selling in person, haggling is to be expected. Don’t be afraid to negotiate with buyers – just be reasonable and fair in your pricing.

Safety first: When selling online or in person, always take precautions to ensure your safety. For example, when meeting up with a buyer, make sure to do so in a public place.

And when shipping items, be sure to use a secure and tracked shipping service.

Be honest about the condition:  When selling beanie babies, be honest about their condition. If there are any flaws or damage, make sure to mention this in your listing/description.

Seek appraisal if you have no idea:   If you have beanie babies that you’re not sure about, it might be worth seeking professional appraisal. This can help to ensure that you’re getting a fair price for your items.

Get an idea of what people are willing to pay: Look around online and see what similar items are selling for. This will give you a good starting point for setting your prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is It Worth Trying To Sell Beanie Babies?

Yes,  it is worth trying to sell beanie babies. There are still people, especially collectors, out there who are interested in buying them.

To get the most money for your beanie babies, focus on selling items that are rare or in good condition. And be sure to take good photos and write detailed descriptions to make your listings more appealing to buyers.

Where Can I Go To See If My Beanie Baby Is Worth Money?

There are a few different places you can go to check on the value of your beanie baby.

One option is to search for similar items on online marketplaces like eBay. This can give you an idea of how much people are willing to pay for items like yours.

Another option is to seek professional appraisal. This can be expensive, but it’s a good way to get an accurate evaluation of your beanie baby’s value.

What Are The Most Valuable Beanie Babies?

The most valuable beanie babies are typically those that are rare or in good condition. Some of the most expensive beanie babies have sold for hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Some of the most valuable beanie babies include:

1. Princess Bear: $500,000

2. Bubbles the Fish: $129,000

3. Piccadilly Attic: $125,000

4. Batty: $125,000

5. Jolly the Walrus: $75,000

To learn more about the value of beanie babies, check out our article  on the subject.

Is There A Market For Old Beanie Babies?

Yes,  there is still a market for old beanie babies. While the craze for these items has died down somewhat in recent years, there are still many people – especially collectors – who are interested in buying them.

To get the most money for your beanie babies, focus on selling items that are rare or in good condition. And be sure to take good photos and write detailed descriptions to make your listings more appealing to buyers.

Where can I sell my Beanie Babies for money?

There are a few different options for selling beanie babies. You can sell them online on sites like eBay or Etsy, or you can sell them in person at flea markets or garage sales.

To get the most, understand the value, collection and then move forward with the preferred platform.

Where is the best place to sell a Beanie Baby?

There is no one “best” place to sell a beanie baby. It depends on factors like the type of beanie baby you’re selling and how much money you’re hoping to get for it.

Some people prefer to sell online, using sites like eBay or Etsy. This can be a good option if you want to reach a large number of potential buyers.

Others prefer to sell in person, either at flea markets or garage sales. This can be a good option if you want to avoid the fees associated with selling online.

What are some places where I can’t sell my Beanie Baby?

There are a few places where you likely won’t be able to sell your beanie baby, such as:

1. Local toy stores: Most local toy stores probably won’t be interested in buying beanie babies, since the craze for these items has died down in recent years.

2. National chain stores: Bigger stores like Walmart or Target also probably won’t be interested in buying beanie babies.

3. Online marketplaces: Some online marketplaces, such as Amazon, have strict policies against selling used items. So you likely won’t be able to sell your beanie baby on these sites.

Conclusion: Where to sell beanie babies

If you have beanie babies that you’re looking to sell, there are a few things you can do to maximize your chances of getting a good price.

Focus on selling rare or well-conditioned items, take good photos and write detailed descriptions, and consider seeking professional appraisal if you’re unsure of your beanie baby’s value.

With a little effort, you should be able to find a buyer who’s willing to pay a fair price for your beanie babies.

Hi buttercup, thank you for stopping by. We’re Chhavi & Amit.

We’re a couple who quit our high paying jobs as a lawyer and an engineer to start hustling online. Now we’re full time bloggers, YouTubers, work at home expert and Online Business Coaches featured on Forbes, Business Insider, Readers Digest, CEO Blog Nation, Starter Story, Yahoo! Finance, MSN, BankRate and so much more.

Say a hi here.

Where to sell beanie babies near me