Skip to Content

Teacher Invites All The 1st Graders to a Barbecue Except One. Says, “He Didn’t Earn ALL Good Noodle Stickers”. Thinks It’s FAIR. Is It?

Teachers often have to make difficult decisions about how to reward or discipline their students. One such decision is whether or not to invite all students to a class barbecue. Some teachers believe that it is important to include all students, regardless of their behavior.

A user asked, Am I wrong for not inviting all students to a barbecue?

Backstory

Homeschooling. Asian family with daughter doing homework by using tablet with mother help. Asia mom and child learning online with laptop computer together in the living room at home

Image Credits: Deposit Photos.

The Original Poster (OP) is a 30-year-old teacher. She has a class with 24 students and teaches 1st grade.

What Did She Do?

middle school teacher

Image Credits: Deposit Photos.

She told her students they could have a barbecue at a park (with hotdogs, hamburgers, and snacks) for whoever filled their “good noodle” sticker charts. The principal has approved this, and she teaches at a private school.

What Does OP Say

feeling stressed, worried, anxious or scared, with hands on head, panicking at mistake

Image Credits: Deposit Photos

OP says, “We have daily sticker charts to track their behavior in school. They had to have perfect behavior all of April to participate.”

There Was One Student With Behavioral Issues

Child in a school library

Image Credit: rmarmion, Deposit Photos

She has one student who has some behavioral issues. They did not earn all of their good noodle stickers this month. Since this student – OP decides to call Bobby – didn’t earn the barbecue, OP had let his mother know just in case he mentioned it.

What Would He Do

Lonely,Sad,African-american,Schoolgirl,Crying,While,All,Her,Classmates,Ignoring

Image Credits: Inside Creative House, Shutterstock

Bobby would join another class for the day and do work inside while his classmates were at the barbecue.

What Did The Parent Do?

baby tantrum

Image Credits: Deposit Photos

Bobby’s mother has been sending emails complaining to OP and the principal all week about how her child should be able to participate, which is unfair.

She thinks they should make an exception since he has behavioral issues and feels we could be targeting him. OP thinks she is being fair because he did not earn all his good noodle stickers.

OP wants to know if she is a jerk.

What We Understand From Comments

Photo of young attractive brunette curly hair lady speechless unexpected reaction bad news global poverty problem isolated on blue color background.

Image Credits: Deposit Photos

Some of your comments specify that this kid has an IEP.

A user says, “100% a jerk. A kid that young who already has an IEP is never going to be able to meet that level of behavioral expectation, regardless of whatever accommodations the IEP calls for.

Perfection for a month! You set this kid up to fail. Hopefully, not on purpose, but that’s still the outcome. Learn from this in the future.”

They’re 1st Graders

mom and son

Image Credit; Deposit Photos

“You are a jerk. As a former educator, I wouldn’t say I like these kinds of public exclusionary rewards, ESPECIALLY for young kids. These are 1st graders. From what you’ve posted, this was the only student excluded. No way will this encourage better behavior from this young child in the future.

Kids, especially young ones, often act out, reacting to emotional stimuli they don’t have the appropriate tools to process. 99% of the time, a kid in 1st grade who is acting out has trouble somewhere – stress/problems at home, getting bullied, who knows. For the same reason, it’s unfair to punish young kids for tardiness or attendance issues; it’s unfair to expect a kid this young to “behave” all the time when you have no idea what might be happening in their lives that isn’t in their control.

Publicly excluding one child is going to make behavior issues worse. You’re turning them into a pariah to their peers – kids can be mean and honestly don’t need much to single someone out as “other.”

I know you want to use some kind of reward system for the kids who are behaving the way you want, but you’re talking about 6 year olds! Something as big as a BBQ at the park should have been an all-or-nothing class goal. Singling out the one kid who is having trouble (which, again, you as the teacher will almost NEVER know the true source of) is bullying.

If these were high schoolers that would be one thing – teenagers are more mature and can be expected to have more control over their behavior – but we’re talking about kids who are only SIX years old.

You need to rethink your reward system, keeping in mind age-appropriate expectations for these children.”

This Is A Bad System

International beauty contest. Kid wear golden crown symbol of princess. Become princess. Lady little princess. Girl wear crown. Princess manners. Award concept. Winner of beauty competition.

Image Credit; Deposit Photos

“This is what really gets me. It’s such an unrealistic expectation. The child has issues, and they only messed up once in a whole month.

That seems worth celebrating, not punishment. If you are setting up a system and it’s possible for all but one child to succeed, it’s a lousy system, especially at this age. There needs to be some safeguard.”

I Wouldn’t Have My Child Go To School That Day

Portrait of a dissatisfied girl standing isolated over yellow background, gesturing

Image Credit; Deposit Photos

“Expecting first graders to be good all month is already hard enough as is, but excluding some of the kids while the rest have fun? This wouldn’t be okay with me if I were a parent.

I wouldn’t have my child go to school on that day. You’re a jerk.”

This Isn’t Age Appropriate

a family quarrel divorce parents and child swear, conflict

Image Credit; Deposit Photos

“You’re wrong. Perfect behavior for an entire month is not an age-appropriate expectation for 1st graders.

At that age, shorter-term rewards are more effective.”

We All Have Bad Days

Young woman standing over blue background afraid and terrified with fear expression stop gesture with hands, shouting in shock. panic concept.

Image Credit; Deposit Photos

“You’re wrong. singling out a child you know has behavioral issues and possibly can’t control certain things, and you’re punishing them for it?

I’m glad our teachers recognize effort, we all have bad days, and this is one of your massive ones! Glad you don’t teach my kids!”

Father Corrects Teacher’s Pronunciation of Daughter’s Name; School Accuses Him of ‘Questioning Authority’. Is This Ok?

Adult hispanic catholic priest man over isolated background clueless and confused expression with arms and hands raised. Doubt concept.

Image Credits: Deposit Photos

A netizen recently asked, Am I a jerk for correcting my daughter’s teacher about her name? Read on to know what happened and drop your comments.

Husband Refuses to Help Wife’s Friend After Her Friend Suggests He Is Hitting On Her. Wife Calls It “Silly Misunderstanding”. Is It Though?

Young sad couple, family having financial problems, depression, crisis. People divorce, stress concept.

Image Credits: Deposit Photos

It’s frustrating to be kind to someone who is important to your partner, only to be accused of something you didn’t do and have your and have your feelings dismissed. Read more.

Couple Kicks Out Groom’s Family For “Violating Rules” At The Wedding. Explains, “They All Wore White and Brought Children To A Child-Free Wedding”. Family Calls It “Traditions”

1. couple fight

Image Credits: Deposit Photos

Mutual respect is very important, especially when you are moving into a new family. What do you think about this?

Boyfriend’s Asks Girlfriend To “Let It Go” After Friends Accused Her Of Cheating On Him, Yells At Her Until Proven Innocent. Should She Let Her Go?

Young couple on a date at the cafe

Image Credits: Deposit Photos

Love is the foundation of a healthy relationship, but trust and respect are essential pillars that support it. Read more, and decide.

Teacher Invites All The 1st Graders to a Barbecue Except One. Says, “He Didn’t Earn ALL Good Noodle Stickers”. Thinks It’s FAIR. Is It?

middle school teacher

Image Credits: Deposit Photos.

A user asked, Am I wrong for not inviting all students to a barbecue? You decide.

This article was originally published on Mrs. Daaku Studio.